What is a Voluntary Contribution?

Compulsory donation refers to the behavior of the donor who does not out of his sympathy for the weak, the persecuted, etc., but invests in circumstances of external hostility or persecution by external forces.

Compulsory donation

Right!

Compulsory donation refers to the behavior of the donor who does not out of his sympathy for the weak, the persecuted, etc., but invests in circumstances of external hostility or persecution by external forces.

Chinese name

Compulsory donation

Definition

Hostage or persecution by external forces

Doubt

Disguised access to social funds

Comment

Is an illegal act

Because this kind of compulsory donation is the behavior of the donor under the external coercive situation, rather than the voluntary consent of the donor, this kind of donation is a bit difficult for others. Alienated donations.

Can compulsory donations contribute charity? ^[1]

What is a mandatory donation? ^[2]

The county committee and county government of Changsha County, Hunan Province jointly issued a document asking all levels and departments to make the One Day Charity Donation activity a political task and an important task; the County Civil Affairs Bureau arranged the task and required public officials, teachers and even ordinary workers to donate one yuan per day. Money, and since last year rounded up the donation amount to 400 yuan per person per year; the county charity association opened a special account in the county finance bureau to accept donations, and donated 3.12 million yuan to the account last year (Central People's Broadcasting Station on September 1st) ).

Mandatory donations are bad. Everyone understands this truth, but I still have to say that the bad nature of forced donations has been seriously underestimated. People generally think that compulsory donations damage the credibility of charity and hurt people's love. In fact, the problem is more than that! Compulsory donations are to force people to pay money for no reason. To put it mildly, this has nothing to do with arbitrary fees and fines the difference.

Because we underestimate the terrible nature of compulsory donations, so that there are no targeted penalties in laws and regulations. In the "People's Republic of China's Public Welfare Donation Law", there are only provisions that "donations should be voluntary and unpaid, and forced or disguised apportionment is forbidden," but there is no corresponding penalty for violators. Judging from this rule, compulsory donations are obviously an illegal act, but the price paid by offenders is limited to compulsory donations being stopped, at most they are criticized and educated.

Why is there a lack of penalties for compulsory donations? It is simply because compulsory donations appear to be good intentions, but they are not done properly. In fact, this view also underestimates the bad nature of compulsory donations and fails to see its true colors. Is compulsory donation really good intention? Not necessarily. On the one hand, as long as the forcibly collected property is in the hands of government departments, it will be difficult to be supervised and restrained. Some of it will be used for charity, and some may be used for other purposes; on the other hand, it is the government's obligation to help the poor For example, to help the elderly orphaned, to subsidize low-income groups, and to support poor schools, these expenses should have come from local finances, but some local governments are unwilling to use financial expenditures, so they force people to donate, thereby saving financial expenses, and mandatory donations have almost become Second Finance. " And where are the saved financial funds used? Just look at the rising data of the "three public" funds in various places, and look at the image projects and performance projects in various places. Why are some local governments keen to donate? Perhaps the biggest secret is here.

The true nature of compulsory donations is far uglier than we think, and its nature is far worse than we think. In order to curb compulsory donations, relevant laws and regulations should introduce punishment provisions to make strong donors punishable by law. At least, the relevant central government departments should issue a decree clearly specifying the accountability system for compulsory donations, and disciplinary actions against strong donors. In any case, compulsory donation is an illegal act, and any illegal cost cannot be zero.